Tainted Grail Romance Guide: Alisa vs. Morgen – Which Love Story Should You Choose?

Looking for love in a world plagued by corruption, betrayal, and monstrous gods? Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon offers two very different romance paths: Alisa, the resilient seamstress with a tragic past, and Morgen, the alluring mermaid whose kiss is far from a fairytale.

In this romance guide, we’ll break down:

  • How to unlock each romance

  • The pros and cons of Alisa and Morgen

  • Their impact on your story

  • And which path is best based on your playstyle

Spoilers are hidden where possible to keep things safe for the curious.


💖 Alisa – A Love Built on Loss, Loyalty & Lies

Who is she?
Alisa is a grounded, human companion you’ll meet in the village tavern. Her story explores survival, grief, and second chances.

🧵 How to Romance Alisa:

    Tainted Grail Romance Guide: Alisa vs. Morgen
  1. Help Her Fight Back
    Accept her quest to clear a nearby manor overrun by bandits.

  2. Flirt Early and Often
    Use flirtatious dialogue during and after the mission to stay on her romance path.

  3. Her Husband’s Secret 🔒 Spoiler Toggle
    [Spoiler: You’ll encounter her presumed-dead husband. If you lie about his fate, Alisa's romance path stays open.]

  4. Support Her Business
    Encourage her to open a tailor shop. You’ll need to gather:

    • Ragged Nobleman's Doublet

    • Silk Gloves

    • Seashells (from Drowners)

  1. Fix the Pier
    Rebuild the pier outside her house to unlock a romantic walk.

  2. Sincere Dialogue Wins
    During the final date, choose heartfelt responses to fully commit to the relationship.

✅ Alisa Romance Pros:

  • Deep emotional connection

  • Unlocks “Yours Forever” achievement

  • Companion becomes part of your home life

  • Influences future narrative options

❌ Alisa Romance Cons:

  • Requires multiple side objectives

  • You must lie in a key moral moment

  • Missable if you choose wrong responses


🌊 Morgen – A Dangerous Beauty with a Deadly Secret

Who is she?
Morgen is a mystical mermaid-like entity tied to the Wyrdness. Her romance route is short, haunting—and lethal.

🐚 How to Romance Morgen:

  1. Start ‘Deep Calleth Upon Deep’ Quest
    Found in a hidden Wyrdness location.

  2. Return Her Treasure
    After retrieving her chest, flirt with lines like:

    • “I've never been with someone like you.”

    • (Move closer)

  3. What Happens Next? 🔒 Spoiler Toggle
    [Spoiler: Morgen seduces and then kills you in a scripted scene. You respawn, but the romance ends there.]

✅ Morgen Romance Pros:

  • Striking, cinematic sequence

  • Offers rare lore about the Wyrdness

  • High-risk moment for roleplay-heavy players

❌ Morgen Romance Cons:

  • Always ends in death

  • No achievements or long-term effects

  • Romance cannot be continued afterward


🆚 Alisa vs. Morgen: Which Romance Is Right for You?

Feature                Alisa                                                            Morgen
Romance DepthLong-term companion romanceOne-time fatal encounter
OutcomeLiving partner, story impactDeath, no lasting benefit
AchievementsYes (Yours Forever)None
Narrative ValueEmotional arc, multiple questsBrief lore-heavy moment
Player AgencyDialogue- and quest-based progressionSingle decision, no branching

💬 Final Verdict

Choose Alisa if you want a meaningful, lasting relationship with narrative consequences. Her path is built on trust, moral choices, and shared hardship.

Choose Morgen if you're a lore junkie chasing the darker, mythic side of Avalon—or if you just want to see what happens when you follow temptation into the Wyrdness.

Either way, Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon ensures that romance, like everything else in its world, comes at a price.


💬 Community Tip:

Want to see other romance routes added in a future patch? Share your thoughts with the devs on Steam Discussions or r/TaintedGrail

Related Articles:

Comments